Flypaper

That's my take on the new Marcus Winters/Jay Greene/Julie Trivitt study on the impact of high-stakes testing on low-stakes subjects in Florida. According to its executive summary, the study examined whether labeling schools with an "F" motivated them to increase learning in science, even though it didn't "count" in the Sunshine State's accountability system:

-- The F-grade sanction produced after one year a gain in student science proficiency of about a 0.08 standard deviation. These gains are similar to those in reading and appear smaller than the gains in math that were due to the F sanction.

--There is some evidence to suggest that student science proficiency increased primarily because student learning in math and reading enabled that increase. That is, learning in math and reading appear to contribute to learning in science.

    That sounds reasonable enough to me, though Eduwonkette wants to see all the technical details to know whether the methodology stands up. (I'm not smart enough to figure that out; that's why we have Amber!)

    My beef is with the study's pre-release spin. The Greene Machine directly juxtaposes its paper with statements by our...

    Liam Julian

    The folks at The Corner are having some debate about Louisiana's Science Education Act.

    (Don't miss tomorrow's Gadfly, which promises additional opining on this topic.)

    Photo by Flickr user jason_coleman.

    Liam Julian

    Yesterday, he who is the Democrat presumed nominated, Barack Obama, said this:

    You know, I don't understand when people are going around worrying about, "We need to have English-only." They want to pass a law, "We want English-only."

    Now, I agree that immigrants should learn English. I agree with that. But understand this. Instead of worrying about whether immigrants can learn English--they'll learn English--you need to make sure your child can speak Spanish. You should be thinking about, how can your child become bilingual? We should have every child speaking more than one language.

    You know, it's embarrassing when Europeans come over here, they all speak English, they speak French, they speak German. And then we go over to Europe, and all we can say [is], "Merci beaucoup." Right?

    I wonder if??his assertion that "they'll learn English" is necessarily true, especially if they refers to kids whose parents may speak no English at home and who are??enrolled in lousy schools (or bilingual education classes). The word??learn is certainly vague--when Obama says "they'll learn English," does he mean that students will be able to communicate verbally, or that they'll be able to write decently, or that they'll both speak...

    Liam Julian

    "Gambling addict gets 18 months for embezzling schools"

    It started with small stuff, like overhead projectors. But when she bet the library in a game of high-stakes hold???em, the clinic on red, and the playground on Federer, and lost them all, administrators suspected something was amiss.

    Liam Julian

    Here's a fine wrap-up, from Ed Week (subscription required, but why?),??of the NEA convention.??The article's??title, "NEA President-Elect Pledges to Stay the Course," tells you??most of what??you need to know.??With the NEA, after all, it's??"Solidarity Forever."

    Totally creepy.

    Liam Julian

    AP reports that he'll do it next week when he speaks at the NAACP convention.

    Update: More from Campaign K-12.

    Liam Julian

    Here's more on TJ, i.e, Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology, in Fairfax County, Virginia.

    Bobby Jindal may be wrong in trying to get religion back into science classrooms but at least he's playing by the (text)book. MSNBC reported yesterday that a science teacher in Mount Vernon, Ohio, burned crosses into the arms of his students.

    Apparently, this purveyor of literal messages was trying to demonstrate a classroom device to students... by using it on them.

    Mike's post about the Obama girls sent me briefly to the website of the University of Chicago lab school that they attend, where I??discovered not only that this PRIVATE school has a teachers union ("faculty association") but also that??administration and union haven't been able to agree on a new contract!

    This is??from the director's latest newsletter:

    At the conclusion of the 2007-2008 school year, the administration and Faculty Association were unable to reach agreement on a new multi-year contract. Ten negotiating sessions were held beginning on February 11 and concluding on June 9. Considerable progress was made on all matters with the exception of salary. Both parties agreed to meet during the third week of August and attempt to reach a conclusion by the beginning of the 2008-2009 school year.

    Will the Democratic candidate for President allow his daughters to cross the teachers'??picket line in September? Or, like the current??dispute between school system and teacher union in Democratic-convention-hosting Denver, will a way be found to patch things up before it embarrasses??the campaign?...

    Liam Julian

    Thusly titled was Dorothy Rabinowitz's??article in yesterday's Wall Street Journal, a piece that looked at the race-based shenanigans that??affected one student at Purdue University.

    Pages