Controversy? In our fair textbook?

Inaccuracies in school textbooks make Gadfly cringe. So does bias. Too many widely-used textbooks are sloppy and error-filled, not to mention banal. Many are also slanted, mainly to the left. Howard Zinn, for example, has peddled his anti-American stuff far and wide and received much acclaim for his trouble. Gary Nash, too. Don't look for investigative reporting to unmask these kinds of textbook flaws. But now that a few contentious assertions have been unearthed in a book written by right-leaning James Q. Wilson and John Dilulio, the Associated Press is beside itself to report the supposed scandal. High-school student Matthew LaClair, who first fingered the folio in question, American Government (a widely-used and generally acclaimed civics text), after perceiving it was "biased," said, "all the statements for the most part were...not giving a fair account of everything." It seems, though, that "all the statements" really means a few short sentences about climate change and church-state relations. Wilson and Dilulio, widely respected scholars both, had no comment. LaClair, who several years ago tape recorded a teacher making a religious remark in class, did have a comment: he's "not looking to cause a huge controversy." Neither is the AP, we're sure.

"Widely used government textbook under fire after high school student raises concerns," by Nancy Zuckerbrod, Associated Press, April 9, 2008

More By Author