Pushing away from CBAs
Reform-minded legislators in a number of states
have begun to challenge teacher evaluation and tenure practices, and
stopping there. Lawmakers in Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, and Tennessee
recently introduced bills that would either limit the scope of
bargaining to wages and benefits or ban the practice altogether.
that eliminating the ability to bargain—particularly over policies such
class size and schedules and hours—will allow school leaders more
set policies best fitted for their schools. In doing so, schools will be
to spend money in a more efficient and targeted manner. Teacher unions,
surprisingly, are none too keen on the idea of losing their right to be
table. But any lawmakers who think they can ease the grip of teacher
simply by eliminating collective bargaining should think again. As
analysts of the education politics of Right to Work states can attest,
groups simply get protections written into state law. While
collective-bargaining agreements no doubt add to the restrictions under
which most schools
and school systems operate, they’re just one piece of a larger puzzle.
Aim to Curb Collective Bargaining,” by Stephen Sawchuk, Education Week, February 9, 2011.
panel OKs bill limiting teacher bargaining,” by Deanna Martin, Boston Globe, January 27, 2011.