Survey: Ohio has a bittersweet relationship with its college students
June 14, 2009
Ohio's best-and-brightest college students may love the Buckeye State, but too many can definitely jilt it for a future elsewhere, according to a new survey from the Thomas B. Fordham Institute.
According to the survey, 88 percent of native Ohioans attending seven top universities in the state are proud of Ohio, but most-51 percent-plan to leave after graduation. Among non-Ohioan undergraduates, 79 percent believes their future lies outside the state.
The survey, Losing Ohio's Future: Why college graduates flee the Buckeye State and what might be done about (see here), fleshes out the problem of the "brain drain" that has been buffeting Ohio for at least a quarter century. However, the survey results are especially disturbing given the state's recession-battered economy, 10-percent unemployment rate (more than 600,000 people on unemployment rolls), the loss of 235,000 jobs in the last year, and attempts to boost not only the state's education system but its high-technology future with massive Third Frontier spending and a focus on green technologies.
We need our best and brightest to invest their energy and future in Ohio to generate the economic vigor, new technologies, and other economic developments that will spur the progress we need to modernize and prosper. They are the key to the state's ability to pay its bills and meet its future promises.
The challenge of keeping our best and brightest in the state contains the possibility for reasonable and feasible response, starting with Ohio's higher-education system. The state is blessed to have 75 four-year institutions of higher education serving more than 620,000 students. Three of these institutions are ranked in the top-100 universities nationally by U.S. News and World Report. Ohio also has 49 two-year institutions of higher learning. Institutions of higher education in Ohio awarded more than 110,000 degrees in 2008.
The FDR Group, a non-partisan opinion-research firm based in New York City, conducted the survey for Fordham. It is believed to be the first study to utilize an Internet social networking site to reach respondents. Using Facebook and random samples provided by colleges, the FDR Group interviewed 811 sophomores, juniors, and seniors at Case Western Reserve University, Kent State University, Miami University, Oberlin College, Ohio State University, Ohio University, and University of Dayton. The results, however, could probably be extended to graduates of all of Ohio's four-year public and private colleges and universities.
Here are some findings:
- Eighty-nine percent say good jobs will be very important in deciding where to live after graduation. Only 11 percent give Ohio excellent prospects.
- Among all students surveyed, 58 percent plan to leave the state (51 percent of native Ohioans and 79 percent of non-Ohioans). Most plan to live where they believe job prospects and cultural and leisure-time activities are better.
- Students are more concerned about success and money than about public service and the environment.
- The ideal job should have good opportunities for promotion and pay increases - 74 percent say this is very important, while 53 percent want work that regularly involves new challenges;
- Fourteen percent say union protection is very important, yet 61 percent say it will be very important to them to find a job with good pension and retirement benefits.
Policymakers are concerned. In 2007, Ohio saw 6,981 more residents between the ages of 25 and 34 leave the state than migrate into it. Scarier still, the more education these young people have, the likelier they are to leave. The Cleveland Plain Dealer found that individuals with master's degrees are more apt to say farewell to Ohio than those with bachelor's degrees, and those with doctoral degrees were twice as likely to leave. The Ohio Board of Regents has highlighted this issue and put some numbers to the brain drain in 2008. Ohio has an annual net loss of more than 5,800 bachelor's degree holders and almost 2,900 graduate degree holders.
With the economy in deep recession and the state facing a $3 billion budget deficit, state leaders are well aware of the fiscal consequences of so much talent leaving. Workers with a high school degree, according to Census figures, earned an average of $31,286 in 2007, while those with a bachelor's degree earned an average of $57,181. What's more, the typical college graduate paid 80 percent more in total federal, state, and local taxes than the typical high school graduate. Those with professional degrees paid almost $19,000 more each in total taxes in 2005 than high school graduates. Yet, Ohio is lagging nationally in keeping and attracting college graduates. The state ranks 30th nationally in the number of citizens between the ages of 25 and 34 with a bachelor's degree.
Late in 2008, U.S. Senator Sherrod Brown (a Democrat) held a summit in Cincinnati with college presidents and business leaders to tackle the "brain drain" problem. Earlier this year, State Senator Steve Buehrer (a Republican) introduced a bill to establish the "Grants for Grads" program to offer grant assistance in the form of house down payments for recent college graduates.
There are practical steps Ohio can take to improve the odds of keeping more of its best and brightest here. The survey offers insights into how they might be convinced to remain:
- Sixty percent say they like the idea of a state cash grant for a down payment on a home as an enticement to remain in Ohio after graduation;
- More than half are very interested in internships in local businesses and organizations (59 percent), co-op programs (53 percent), and opportunities to meet with local companies (52 percent);
- Sixty-five percent say a state income-tax credit for those who stay in-state for 10 years would be appealing.
The Fordham Institute became interested in Ohio's brain-drain issues because of its work to improve public education. We often hear school district officials, especially those serving needy children, lament the difficulty they face in finding and recruiting talented principals and expert teachers in fields like math and science. We also know firsthand, as a charter school authorizer, the difficulties these public schools face in attracting and recruiting great leaders and teachers to work in their schools in the Buckeye State.
In fact, the survey indicates there is opportunity on this front:
- Thirty-seven percent of the students surveyed would consider being a public-school teacher, and another 18 percent would consider other careers in education;
- Among science and math majors, 29 percent would consider teaching in a public school;
- Sixty-one percent of students surveyed like the idea of forgiving student loans for graduates who spend a certain number of years in education.