Flypaper

Laura Pohl

Checker recently visited schools in the slums of Hyderabad, India, where low-budget private schools are educating kids--and doing a pretty good job. Here are some of his thoughts, from a commentary just published on Forbes.com:

In America my efforts to widen education options and promote school choice for poor kids, like the efforts of most U.S. reformers, have always assumed that, at day's end, the government must pay for this. Perhaps that's true in the Western world, perhaps it's not. But elsewhere on the planet, I can now attest, poor families are paying for it themselves and education entrepreneurs are responding to their demand (and their governments' failure) by starting, managing and growing such schools.

Most of them occupy sketchy facilities, sans playgrounds, labs, libraries and fancy technology. Many teachers are themselves just high-school graduates. The kids bring their own lunches. Parents provide transportation and go to the bazaar for textbooks and uniforms. Sports and extracurricular activities are scarce to nonexistent. Neither schools nor families have any money to spare.

But teaching and learning are occurring in those cramped and sometimes ill-lit classrooms. Eager youngsters, prodded by determined parents, are drinking in whatever knowledge and skills

...
Laura Pohl

Stats stud Mark Schneider of the American Institutes for Research graced our studio for the latest Education Gadfly Show podcast episode, now available here. You won't want to miss Mark's pontifications on the latest TIMSS results and his take on "advanced topics" courses. Also: Amber dishes on a charter school study and Stafford reports on yet another way schools are cutting costs (hint: caffeine addicts won't be amused). Listen to all this and more on the Education Gadfly Show!

Guest Blogger

From our intern Charlotte Underwood:

Looks like our earlier post on Denver schools superintendent Michael Bennet had some impact on today's pick-the-next-education-secretary vote. Though Arne Duncan still leads our poll, the Illinois governor's troubles may have sullied the Windy City, hurting Chicago Public Schools chief Arne Duncan's chances of becoming the next education secretary. President-elect Obama is distancing himself from the Gov. Rod Blagojevich controversy, so maybe he will keep it no-drama-Obama and look to Bennet after all. ??Yesterday's boy-wonder Graham Spanier is still quite popular, as is Linda Darling-Hammond.

The newest addition to our Board? Alan Khazei, co-founder of City Year and current CEO of Be The Change inc. A different kind of pick, but Obama did run for president with a community organizer background, so it could make sense.

Where is our money? Still on Duncan...

It's week FIVE, day three. Mr. Obama, if you are listening--we don't know how much longer we can hold out!

...

The Education Gadfly

The Department of Education released its long-anticipated undated FERPA regulations yesterday, to be analyzed by the Data Quality Campaign in the coming weeks (and covered by the Wall Street Journal here.). But don't read those without first turning to Chrys Dougherty's excellent analysis of FERPA - its flaws, history, and possible reforms - in Fordham's A Byte at the Apple. (And for a little humor, check out our FERPA music video - the tragic tale of one education researcher's quest for data.)

We still think Arne Duncan is the likely pick for education secretary, but what if, for whatever reason (say, the stench of scandal emanating from the Windy City), Team Obama decides to go in another direction? Could Michael Bennet, the Denver superintendent, be the go-to guy? According to this Denver Post article, he's well-liked by reformers and the teachers union (or at least his local teachers union) and politically savvy. He's non-traditional (he used to work in business) and he recently got a nod from Jonathan Alter at Newsweek. (Maybe Alter is friends with his brother James, who edits the Atlantic. It's a small world.) Of course, as the Post points out, he has yet to be mentioned prominently in Flypaper's pick-the-next-education-secretary-daily-tracking-poll. Maybe that will change today!

Photograph of Michael Bennet from The Denver Forum...
Laura Pohl

Mike was on the air again yesterday! NPR's All Things Considered interviewed him for a story on the Trends in??International Mathematics and Science Study results. You can listen to the whole report here; Mike's quote begins at 1:27.

The Education Gadfly

Poor Arne Duncan! First the Illinois Governor goes down in flames. Then Oprah admits she's once again struggling with weight! All in one day! Will bad news from his home turf never cease? Let's hope the Sears Tower, the Cubs and deep dish pizza all steer clear of scandal in coming days.......

Updated Dec. 10, 2008: How could we have forgotten? The Cubs's parent company , Tribune, is in bankruptcy though the Cubs are not part of the Ch. 11 filing.

Guest Blogger

From guest blogger Diane Ravitch, a Fordham board member and research professor at NYU:

I respectfully disagree with the Fordham view on the TIMSS results, especially the conclusion that the small gains posted by 8th grade students in math are "noteworthy."??The gains registered over the past four years are actually small, only four points.

The gains posted by 8th graders are certainly not a vindication??of No Child Left Behind's testing regime. Eighth-graders registered a 12-point gain in math from 1995-2003, before the imposition of NCLB testing. They posted a 4-point gain from 2003-2007. The students who were tested by TIMSS in 2007 had been subject to NCLB annual tests in every year from third grade onward, yet their scores did not show a dramatic improvement. If anything, the gains were no greater (and possibly smaller) than those registered pre-NCLB.

Also, I would point out that Minnesota showed dramatic gains on TIMMS not because of "new, more rigorous??standards," but because of that state's decision to??implement a coherent grade-by-grade curriculum in mathematics. William Schmidt took the lead in developing that curriculum??and deserves to bask in glory for what he has done for the children of Minnesota. That...

The Education Gadfly

Arne Duncan still dominates the field in our pick-the-next-education-secretary poll. Our ten Washington insiders are sticking with the likely nominee, but some voters are looking for the unexpected choice. If not the basketball extraordinaire from Chicago, who might it be? Well, we haven't seen the likes of Graham Spanier or Roy Barnes on the Big Board in quite some time, so maybe some of our insiders have inside information. Spanier is the President at Penn State and Barnes is the former governor of Georgia. Caroline Kennedy, Jon Schnur, Michael Bennet, and Ted Mitchell are still mentioned, but haven't garnered enough support to make it to the top few. Stay posted as the week goes on. We hope this week (5) is the last one.

The Trends in??International Mathematics and Science Study results are out. Here's Fordham's official take:

The latest results of the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) include a few good pieces of news for the U.S. economy. (And these days, we'll take any good economic news we can get.) American students have made steady gains in mathematics performance over the past decade. This progress was especially noteworthy at the eighth grade level, where the U.S. made gains since 1995 that were at least as strong as all of our major economic competitors. (The news was not as good in fourth grade, where several countries, including England and Hong Kong, made dramatic gains far outpacing ours.) Considering that researchers have found a strong correlation between performance on international exams such as TIMSS and long-term economic growth, this progress bodes well for the American economy. (Of course, we still have a long way to go before we close the gap with top-scoring countries.)

However, the story on science is much more discouraging. American students actually lost ground in fourth grade science, seeing their scores slip three points over the past decade while seven countries (including Singapore, Hong Kong,...

Pages